Bayport Cove Auction of 1907: Who Bought the Great South Bay Dream?

 

Bayport Cove Auction of 1907: Who Bought the Great South Bay Dream?

On Saturday, July 6, 1907, history was made in Bayport, Long Island. Seventy-six plots of land fronting the Great South Bay and Merrick Road were sold by John L. Parish, Auctioneer, in an "absolute, unreserved auction." According to the New York Daily Tribune ad from June 23, 1907, the lots were marketed as an "unusual opportunity" to own waterfront property in what was called the "Aristocratic Section of Long Island."

Each plot was approximately 100 feet by 150 feet, and the promise of free transportation, proximity to the Bayport LIRR station (just two blocks away), and a private pier made this an irresistible offer—especially for summer residences of bankers, brokers, capitalists, and even “professional men.”

What is Merrick Road Today?

“Merrick Road” referred to in the ad is likely what we now know as Montauk Highway (NY-27A). This major route still runs through Bayport and connects the South Shore of Long Island from Babylon to Montauk. The stretch of land described in the auction ad may very well correspond to what is now the Bayport Marina or the Bayport-Blue Point Beach, both located just south of Montauk Highway and about two blocks from the Bayport LIRR station.

Who Bought the Property?

While specific names of early buyers from the 1907 auction aren’t readily available in public record databases, this section of Bayport soon filled with summer homes and seaside retreats. Over the decades, the area attracted attention from prominent families and celebrities.

It’s been said that Anne Hathaway and Isabella Rossellini have either owned homes or summered in Bayport Village, adding to its reputation as an artistic, tranquil enclave. Rossellini’s long-standing ties to Long Island through her environmental and farming efforts (at her nearby Brookhaven property) lend some credibility to this rumor.

Who Lives There Today?

While we can’t share private owner details for privacy reasons, Bayport remains a highly desirable hamlet, known for its beautiful waterfront, historic homes, and close-knit community. Property values in the area reflect the enduring charm first marketed back in 1907. It remains one of the last true village-style communities on the South Shore.

If you have family records, photos, or deeds connecting you to this 1907 auction or early Bayport ownership, I’d love to hear your story in the comments!